A Child with a Suitcase: An Unacceptable Arrangement That Split a Childhood Across Three Homes
Imagine an eight-year-old child who is always packed.
Not because they are going on a trip.
Not because it is the holidays.
But because their life is divided between three homes in a single week.
Today I spoke with the mother of an eight-year-old child. The case is taking place in Switzerland.
In the course of my work I have heard many stories about disputes between parents and about court decisions. I thought there was little left that could surprise me.
This case, however, left me speechless for a moment.
The court decided that the eight-year-old child would live like this:
- 2 days with the father
- 2 days with the mother
- 3 days with a foster family
That is what the child’s week looks like.
A child who lives out of a suitcase
From our conversation I understood one more thing.
This child is practically always packed in a suitcase.
Two days here.
Two days there.
Three days somewhere else.
Constant moving. Constant packing. Always a new environment, new rules, a new bed.
Their things move with them – clothes, school things, toys. Something stays with one parent, something with the other, something with the foster family.
But the things are actually the least of it.
What is worse is what is happening in the mind of an eight-year-old child.
According to the mother, the child is more and more confused. They ask questions that a child of this age should never have to deal with:
Where do I actually live?
Where are my things?
Where is my home?
And perhaps the hardest question of all:
Where do I actually belong?
An arrangement that should not exist
That is exactly why, from the point of view of a child’s needs, such an arrangement is unacceptable.
Not because one of the parents must necessarily be bad or dangerous.
But because an eight-year-old child simply cannot live a stable life if their home changes every two days.
A child needs:
- stability
- a sense of safety
- predictability
- one clear home
Not three homes in a single week.
Shared care – a solution for parents, not for children?
In recent years, shared care has increasingly been described as a modern and fair solution.
Fair for whom?
For the parents, perhaps.
But for the child?
Children do not need time fairly divided between adults.
Children need a home.
A home is not a place you move away from every two days.
A home is a place where you know you belong.
A child should not pay for the decisions of adults
Personally, I am convinced of one thing:
A child should have one home.
If the parents cannot agree, if their relationship has ended and a solution has to be found, then it is the adults who should adapt.
Not the child.
If anyone is to take turns, it should be the parents.
Not an eight-year-old child who is still looking for security in the world.
Childhood should not look like endlessly packing a suitcase.
Let us open a discussion
This case from Switzerland is not just about one family.
It is also about a wider question that arises in many European countries.
Where is the line between parents’ rights and a child’s real needs?
Is it fair to split time with a child exactly in half
if the result is that the child has no single home?
Or should we start thinking the other way round:
that a child should have one stable home – and the parents should adapt to the child, not the other way round.
Need help with a similar situation?
We support Slovak and Czech families in the UK – in confidence, free of charge.
Contact us